What’s the plan?

The Prime F. Osborn Convention Center

JTA, along with the City of Jacksonville and the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT), have applied for a $35 million federal grant through the Consolidated Rail Infrastructure and Safety Improvement (CRISI) program. The project, supported by CSX and Florida East Coast Railway (FEC), would restore the city’s rail and signaling infrastructure particularly on the FEC corridor. If successful, it would fix San Marco’s freight train chokepoint problem. According to JTA, “by improving the movement of freight rail, this project will enhance mobility, improve safety, support economic development and ease access to the medical district in the Southbank that includes Baptist Medical Hospital, Baptist MD Anderson Cancer Center, Wolfson Children’s Hospital and Nemours Children’s Hospital.”

These improvements could also open the door for bringing passenger rail back Downtown. Restoring rail service to the Prime F. Osborn Convention Center - built as the Jacksonville Union Terminal - has long been a dream of downtown and transit advocates. The grand building in LaVilla was the country’s largest passenger station south of Washington, D.C. when it opened in 1919, serving 20,000 passengers a day. In 1974, declining use led Amtrak to move its services five miles northwest to a much smaller building colorfully known as an “Amshack.”

Ever since Amtrak’s move, the city has sought ways to bring trains rolling back to the Prime Osborn. Since the 1990s this vision has been paired with the dream of establishing a local commuter rail service. In addition to providing a new transit option, commuter rail is well known for its potential to spark development near stations, two things Downtown Jacksonville could desperately use. While commuter rail has never gotten much past the conceptual phase in Jacksonville, at August 2018 board meeting, JTA CEO Nat Ford told the Jacksonville Business Journal that commuter rail at the Prime Osborn is a specific goal of the grant bid. Could this project be a turning point?

What else is involved?

A rendering of JTA’s Jacksonville Regional Transportation Center, currently under construction.

The grant bid comes amid a period of significant growth for both JTA and LaVilla. In the private sector, four apartment complexes are under construction or recently completed in the area, while JTA is currently building the Jacksonville Regional Transportation Center directly across from the Prime Osborn. Scheduled to open in 2019, the JRTC is planned to house city and intercity buses, bus rapid transit, and the Jacksonville Skyway in one facility. Adding a train station to the mix would make for one hell of a transit complex.

All this energy fulgurating through LaVilla isn’t lost on the city. An Urban Land Institute panel urged the city to pull out all stops to make a train station happen, and JTA is partnering with the Downtown Investment Authority (DIA) for a series of public meetings on the future of the district. As it has been in many cities, passenger rail could be transformative for LaVilla and Downtown.

The Brightline connection

Brightline operates high-speed intercity rail service between Miami and West Palm Beach. Plans are underway to extend the system to Orlando and Tampa.

Florida East Coast Railway, which owns the mainline tracks that run through Downtown and San Marco all the way to Miami, is supporting JTA’s grant bid. This is intriguing in the fact that FEC is under the same corporate umbrella as Brightline, the country’s first privately-owned passenger rail system since the 1980s. Brightline runs trains between Miami and West Palm Beach, with plans to reach Orlando, along the FEC corridor - the same corridor that JTA hopes to restore in Jacksonville. Though it’s been little reported on locally, Brightline has made no secret of its desire to expand to Jacksonville and beyond. As Brightline has sparked millions of dollars of development with each station, bringing the system to Jacksonville’s transit complex would be a huge boon for Jacksonville and Downtown.

The project would also open up possibilities for Amtrak, which currently doesn’t use the FEC tracks through Jacksonville. New infrastructure could be the catalyst needed to return Amtrak to its rightful place in the Prime Osborn. If successful, JTA’s project could ultimately bring commuter rail and two intercity systems to Jacksonville’s transit center.

Can it work?

The Consolidated Rail Infrastructure and Safety Improvement grant is highly competitive. Though JTA can make a great case for its project, there’s only $318 million to go around, and Jacksonville alone would need $35 million of it. It’s a big ask. Even if it’s successful, JTA has informed The Jaxson that it currently has no concrete plans for passenger rail on the table, so years of planning would be necessary before any passenger service came online.

But regardless of whether the current application is successful, it’s positive to see city agencies starting to rail seriously. For decades, rail investment has been deferred, treated as a future initiative for an unspecified later date, while other cities have planned and established rail systems in the same amount of time. As such, Jacksonville has missed redevelopment opportunities that have come to peer cities like Charlotte, Orlando and Salt Lake City. JTA’s bid is a sign that Jacksonville is moving in the right direction to establish a long-term vision for passenger rail. Jacksonville may miss out on this particular bid, but with a vision, the city will be well placed to catch the next one that rolls up to the Prime Osborn.

Article by Bill Delaney. Contact Bill at wdelaney@moderncities.com